It has been public knowledge for years
that the Navy intends to dredge Key West Harbor. It now
appears that the first real dredging the harbor has seen
in almost 40 years will begin soon.
But with the project only months
away -- and the contract already given to a private
contractor -- the public remains unaware of most of the
details of this important, expensive and environmentally
sensitive project.
Last week, the new commanding
officer of Naval Air Station Key West, Capt. Jim Scholl,
spoke to the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary
Advisory Council's Large Ship Working Group and provided
more details about the project, including the news that
plans for disposal of the dredged material have changed.
Now the Navy plans to haul clean rock and sand to a
disposal site 13 miles offshore, while sludge that could
be contaminated will be taken to Fleming Key.
Environmental agencies, including
the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary and the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency, have been kept abreast of
these developments, and that's good. But the general
public has been left in the dark. Given the importance of
Key West Harbor to the community, economically and
culturally, that must change.
Originally, the Outer Mole at
Truman Annex was to be conveyed to the city, along with
the rest of the property. After Sept. 11, and after the
Navy decided to remove training operations from Puerto
Rico, Key West and its excellent harbor regained some of
its strategic value in the eyes of the Navy.
The Navy decided to hold onto the
Outer Mole, and continue allowing the city to lease the
facility for cruise ship docking. Capt. Scholl said last
week that the Navy needs to dredge the harbor in order to
accommodate the cruisers and destroyers that will come
here for training and maintenance. The prospect of
increased Navy ship visitation at Key West is welcome,
both for the economic infusion it will bring to the city
and for the diversification it promises to the economy.
Many are also hopeful that the
dredging, done properly, will be an overall environmental
benefit to the harbor, by removing the loose sediments
that get stirred up when cruise ships enter or leave the
harbor and cause the plumes that are plainly visible
behind the ships.
But given the sensitivity of the
coral reef environment, and the importance of the marine
environment to the community, some are also worried that
the dredging will go farther than the caprock and create a
deeper harbor to facilitate more cruise ships. There is
also likely to be concern about the fate of the spoil that
is dumped on the ocean bottom offshore.
To answer questions, the Navy
ought to expand its public information efforts
immediately, with community meetings, presentations to the
Key West City Commission and other groups, as well as a
Web site with plentiful information about its plans.
Key West's historic legacy and
its current economy depend heavily on its harbor. Such a
major project affecting such an important public asset
should not be a mystery to its citizens.